driversOnline, point drive vs distributed drive
Learning With Errors
cones & films

Starter draft. The mechanism is standard driver physics; the demo is a real phase-lag model (a cone driven at one point against a film driven everywhere), not a measurement. Background paraphrased from Wikipedia and the usual headphone references.

aadharsh

planar magnetic vs dynamic drivers. audiophiles talk about planars like a different species. what actually changes between them?

drivers

How the diaphragm gets pushed. A dynamic driver glues a voice coil to a cone and parks it in a magnet gap; current through the coil makes a force at that one spot, and the cone has to carry that push out to its edges. A planar driver etches the conductor across a thin flat film hung between two magnet arrays, so the force lands evenly over the whole surface.

aadharsh

so one pushes at a point, the other pushes everywhere. why does that matter?

drivers

At low frequencies it barely does; the cone moves as one piston either way. The split shows up high, where the wavelength inside the diaphragm gets short. A point-driven cone has to propagate that motion outward, so the rim starts lagging the center and the surface stops moving as one piece. It breaks into modes. The flat film, driven everywhere at once, stays flat.

watch the diaphragm move · drag the frequency

Top: a dynamic cone driven at one point (the voice coil, the dark bar at the center). Bottom: a planar membrane driven evenly across its area (the row of bars). Drag the frequency: the cone's rim lags its center and the surface breaks up, while the planar sheet stays flat.

aadharsh

so those ripples in the top one are the cone breaking up. that's distortion?

drivers

It is. When different parts of the diaphragm move out of step, they radiate sound that was not in the signal, which shows up as resonance peaks and extra distortion in the treble. Spreading the drive is how planars keep distortion low up high. It is also why a planar diaphragm can be so thin and light: it never has to be stiff enough to stay rigid under a point load.

aadharsh

if planars are cleaner, why isn't everything planar?

drivers

Tradeoffs. Those magnet arrays are heavy and the big flat diaphragm is inefficient, so planars tend to be bigger, heavier on your head, and hungry for amp power. Dynamic drivers are light, cheap, efficient, and move a lot of air easily, which makes deep bass simple and lets them run off a phone. Most headphones in the world are dynamic for exactly those reasons.

aadharsh

so planar trades weight and power for low distortion, and dynamic trades some treble cleanliness for efficiency and easy bass.

drivers

That is the honest summary. Neither wins outright. A well-engineered dynamic driver can sound excellent, and a sloppy planar can sound worse than a good dynamic. The mechanism sets the tendencies; the tuning and the build decide the result.

aadharsh

point drive versus spread-out drive, and the rest follows. thanks.

planar magnetic on Wikipedia · headphones on Wikipedia · back to Learning With Errors

end of first pass
This is a recorded conversation. Drag the frequency in the demo above.